Classic Ross Amico

Tag: Nadia Boulanger

Seymour: An Epilogue

Between the obligation to promote my radio shows every Friday and Saturday, then last week falling ill as I teetered into the weekend, I just couldn’t pull it together to acknowledge the passing of Seymour Bernstein.

Born and raised in Newark, NJ (and no relation to Leonard), Bernstein basically taught piano for 80+ years, from the time his own teacher, Clara Husserl, herself a pupil of Theodor Leschetizky – who studied with Carl Czerny, who studied with Beethoven – delegated the supervision of some of her more gifted, younger pupils to him when he was only 15.

Bernstein also studied with Alexander Brailowsky, Clifford Curzon, and Jan Gorbaty, legendary pedagogue Nadia Boulanger, and master of all trades George Enescu. That is quite the gallery of mentors!

Bernstein was the soloist in the world premiere of Heitor Villa-Lobos’ Piano Concerto No. 2 with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra in 1969. Even at the height of his career as a performer, he taught, conducting master classes in Europe, Asia, and the Americas.

He abandoned the concert stage at the age of 50, opting instead for the quieter satisfactions of teaching and composing. He intimated to no one that his final concert, in 1977, would be his swan song.

His Achilles’ heel was debilitating stage fright. It drove him to early retirement, and later in life, when he was persuaded to go before the cameras for a documentary about him, he blacked out.

He long maintained a private studio in New York City, where he continued to teach practically to the time of his death. His books include “With Your Own Two Hands: Self-Discovery Through Music,” “20 Lessons in Keyboard Choreography,” “Monsters and Angels: Surviving a Career in Music,” and “Chopin: Interpreting His Notational Symbols.”

Warm and funny, dry, opinionated, and always full of insight, Bernstein was a larger-than-life character whose philosophy of musicmaking was always rooted in the heart. He could lull you with that grandfatherly exterior, but watch out! He was as sharp as C-sharp major.

In 2015, that documentary was released. “Seymour: An Introduction” was directed by Princeton’s Ethan Hawke – and if you’re a J.D. Salinger fan, you’ll doubly appreciate the title. The film has a 100-percent fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes. You can watch the trailer here.

A Bernstein interview at the age of 90 on “Living the Classical Life”

There are also hours of fascinating videos on the YouTube channel “tonebase PIANO.” In this one, Bernstein dismantles Glenn Gould’s Mozart.

Bernstein plays Brahms

At 19, playing Liszt’s “Mephisto Waltz No. 1”

Bernstein died on April 30. At the time of his death, he was 99 years old.

R.I.P.

May 6, 2026
Nadia Boulanger Influential Teacher

Nadia Boulanger (1887-1979) has been described as the most influential teacher since Socrates.

Her students included everyone from Dinu Lipatti to Igor Markevitch, from Aaron Copland to Elliott Carter, from Astor Piazzolla to Philip Glass, from Michel Legrand to Quincy Jones, from Leonard Bernstein to “What Makes It Great?” creator Rob Kapilow.

Her influence on American music, in particular, has been incalculable. Hopefuls flocked to her American Conservatory at Fontainebleau, where she accepted applicants from all backgrounds, provided they were determined to learn. It was Virgil Thomson who quipped, “She was a one-woman graduate school, so powerful and permeating that legend credits every United States town with two things: a five and dime and a Boulanger pupil.” The five and dimes may have faded, but not so the legacy of the “Boulangerie.”

Beneath those grey hairs and pince-nez lurked an iron will that brooked no nonsense, yet Boulanger was surprisingly accepting, astonishingly objective, and generally dead-on in her assessments. When asked if a hierarchy could be established among composers – Beethoven being more important than Max Bruch, for instance – she suggests the pointlessness of such comparisons, stating it is like comparing the Himalayas to Montmartre.

She accepted the philosophical breadth of her pupils as a matter of course: “It’s very different to confront a work you don’t know yet, or a work in which you have to recognize some worth, while secretly saying to yourself, ‘that’s a trend I would never follow.’ That’s a matter of personal taste. Cannot culture allow us to go beyond personal taste and see the beauty of an object? I may not want to buy it, but I can see that it’s beautiful.”

We need more of that in our world. Happy birthday, Nadia Boulanger!

Fascinating Boulanger documentary, with first-hand accounts, historical footage, and terrific insights. Leonard Bernstein is interviewed in French, beginning around the 7-minute mark.

Boulanger conducts Fauré’s Requiem

Her sister, Lili, was really the composer in the family. (Sadly short-lived, she died at the age of 24.) Even so, Nadia made some game attempts at composition. Here’s her own “Fantaisie variée” for piano and orchestra.

Three Pieces for Cello and Piano

Playing Brahms waltzes with Dinu Lipatti

September 16, 2025
Bard Music Festival Encounters Fisher Center at Bard

One of the great pleasures of attending the Bard Music Festival is not only the obvious enjoyment that comes from listening to and learning about the subject at hand (this year, Hector Berlioz), but also the sense of conviviality experienced in the company of likeminded music lovers from all walks of life.

Here I am with my newest friend from Bard. No, not Berlioz. That’s Bill Osborne on the left. Bill is a retired organist who studied at Fontainebleau with the venerable pedagogue Nadia Boulanger. For over 40 years, he served as Distinguished Professor of Fine Arts at Denison University.

In that capacity, he also directed the Denison Singers, which brought him to Princeton a couple of times to perform at Westminster Choir College and Princeton University Chapel. He adds impishly that some of their belongings were stolen at Princeton High School. But Bill, a true gentleman and a lovely raconteur, shares all his stories with a laugh and a twinkle in his eye.

As a student in France, he also encountered legendary organist-composers Marcel Dupré and Olivier Messiaen. During one memorable lesson, he was caught on the bench between Boulanger and André Marchal, the celebrated blind organist of St. Germain des Pres, with their at times conflicting philosophies, trying his best to diplomatically serve two masters.

Boulanger was notorious for her strict instruction and strong opinions. Bill observed that she was a stickler for punctuality in her students, yet she herself was always late for lessons. Once, he too was running behind, and he ran into her in the courtyard. Mademoiselle, as she was affectionately known, demanded to know why he wasn’t already at their lesson.

Back in the United States, during the course of some research he was conducting in New York, he was put up in a penthouse at the Dakota. I probably don’t have to tell you about the Dakota. It’s one of the top-tier apartment buildings on Central Park West. Anyway, he got a big kick out of that. The building is so crammed with celebrities that whenever he peered over a balcony a paparazzo would snap his photo from the street, assuming he must be somebody famous.

Once, he walked out of the building just as a limousine pulled up. Who should spring out of the back seat but Leonard Bernstein. In his classic effusive manner, Lenny walked up to Bill, who was agog, and enfolded him in a warm embrace. Lenny said, “So good to see you again,” assuming that, if he lived at the Dakota, he must have known him; but of course, Bill had never seen him before in his life.

Bill was also responsible for introducing the organ works of Petr Eben to the United States, after receiving the scores from the hand of the composer during a tour of Czechoslovakia. He went on to record an album of Eben’s works for Crystal Records.

What an interesting, affable fellow! I enjoyed chatting with him over several days. You never know who you’re going to meet at Bard.

This year’s Bard Music Festival, “Berlioz and His World,” continues through August 18. For more information, follow the link.

https://fishercenter.bard.edu/whats-on/programs/bard-music-festival/

Fisher Center at Bard

August 13, 2024
Colette Maze RIP Centenarian Pianist Dies at 109

If you’re a classical music nut, the Internet Algorithm Overlords may have introduced you to Colette Maze. Maze amazed with her videos of centenarian keyboard dexterity and grace as likely the oldest pianist ever to record. Maze died this week at the age of 109. Her last record was released earlier this year.

In 1929, at the age of 15, she entered the École normale de musique de Paris to study with Alfred Cortot and Nadia Boulanger. Alfred Cortot! This woman was living history. She continued playing daily right up to the very end, the better to maintain her memory. An amazing feat.

The longest-lived pianist I had previously been aware of was one-time Philadelphian Leo Ornstein (founder of the now-defunct Ornstein School of Music). Ornstein, who also gained notoriety as an avant-garde composer, died in 2002 at the age of 106. I have no idea if he was still playing up to that time. He certainly was not recording.

In 2017, I mused about Ornstein’s unlikely resurrection as a video game character. You can read the post here:

https://www.facebook.com/search/top?q=classic%20ross%20amico%20ornstein

Maze plays Debussy at 108

A four-minute tribute from her 106th year

A life dedicated to beauty can never be long enough. R.I.P.

November 22, 2023
Nadia Boulanger: Celebrating the Legendary Teacher

Nadia Boulanger, the grande dame of 20th century music, was born on this date in 1887.

Widely considered to have been the greatest musical pedagogue who ever lived, she was especially instrumental to the development of American composition. Hopefuls flocked to the American Conservatory at Fontainebleau, France, where she accepted applicants from all backgrounds. Her only stipulation was that they be determined to learn. It was Virgil Thomson who quipped, “She was a one-woman graduate school, so powerful and permeating that legend credits every United States town with two things: a five and dime and a Boulanger pupil.” The five and dimes may have faded, but not so the legacy of the “Boulangerie.”

Beneath those grey hairs and pince-nez lurked an iron will that brooked no nonsense, yet Boulanger was surprisingly accepting, astonishingly objective, and generally dead-on in her assessments.

Her students included everyone from Dinu Lipatti to Igor Markevitch, from Aaron Copland to Elliott Carter, from Astor Piazzolla to Philip Glass, from Michel Legrand to Quincy Jones, from Leonard Bernstein (unofficially) to “What Makes It Great?” radio host Rob Kapilow.

Here’s what a few of those who benefited from her tutelage have to say about their experiences with her.

Quincy Jones

Harold Shapero

Elliot Carter

Elliot Carter and Ned Rorem

Fascinating documentary, including first-hand accounts, historical footage, and terrific insights. Leonard Bernstein is interviewed in French, beginning around the 7-minute mark:

There’s a live recording of Mme Boulanger conducting the Requiem of her teacher, Gabriel Fauré, from 1968 that’s circulated on various labels, with the BBC Chorus and BBC Symphony Orchestra. However, this performance too, with the Choral Art Society and the New York Philharmonic, is quite lovely, captured in Carnegie Hall in 1962.

Nadia’s early ambition was to become a composer herself. However, she soon acknowledged that her sister, Lili, was the true talent in this regard and devoted her life to teaching. Sadly, Lili died of Crohn’s Disease at the age of only 24.

Here’s Nadia’s own “Fantaisie variée” for piano and orchestra from 1912, written when she was 25.

And an earlier work, “Cantique” from 1909

Boulanger died in 1979 at the age of 92.

Joyeux anniversaire… et merci!

September 16, 2023

Tag Cloud

RECENT POSTS