“The Nutcracker” as Subversive Family Classic

“The Nutcracker” as Subversive Family Classic

by 

in
5 responses

If you ever detected a sinister undertow in Tchaikovsky’s ballet “The Nutcracker,” the source material, by E.T.A. Hoffmann, is much worse.

Hoffmann’s 1816 story focuses on the Nutcracker’s battle with the evil Mouse King, filtered through the vivid imagination of a doomed dreamer with a perpetual mistrust of adults. It’s Herr Drosselmayer all the way, baby.

It often puzzles me how so many adaptations of Hoffmann’s stories gloss over the sinister and the uncanny elements. “The Nutcracker” has its share of up-tempo numbers. They’re mostly the ones we hear in stores while we’re out Christmas shopping. However, there’s little doubt the composer grasped the inexorable undertow of Hoffmann, since his score conveys plenty of anxiety to counterbalance the twee sweets.

Listen to the bass clarinet slither beneath that glittery celesta in the “Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy.” And what’s all that creeping around, with the disturbing sforzandi? There’s something desperate and perhaps a little manic underpinning the magic.

Maurice Sendak completely gets it. If you have never seen Carroll Ballard’s 1986 film of “The Nutcracker,” with the Sendak designs and dancers of Pacific Northwest Ballet, you should make it a point to do so. Its sugar plums are all steeped in acid. Sir Charles Mackerras conducts the London Symphony Orchestra on the soundtrack.

I’m not even sure I could describe the subtext as Freudian. It’s just out there. And it has the best WTF ending of all “Nutcracker” adaptations.

But if it’s snowflakes and flowers you’re interested in, here’s an extended suite of highlights with the Boston Pops conducted by Arthur Fiedler, on Fiedler’s birthday.

Get crackin’!


Comments

5 responses to ““The Nutcracker” as Subversive Family Classic”

  1. Anonymous

    Is the Sendak version the one where Drosselmeyer is eyeing Clara and she’s uncomfortable? And in the second act Clara’s mother appears as an exotic bird in a cage a la Nora Helmer?

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Claire Pula I can’t recall if it’s her mother in the cage. I’ll have to go back and watch it again (it’s been a few years), but the “Arabian Dance” definitely features a caged woman in a peacock costume. And yes, Clara has an unsettling love-hate fascination with her uncle, Drosselmayr. Their relationship is rather disturbing.

      1. Anonymous

        Indeed

  2. Anonymous

    There are few things worse than disturbing sforzandi creeping about, esp smack in the middle of an attempt at sugary self-exposition.
    (And why does that multi-headed rat remind me, in a slightly less-than-sentimental way, of several middle-school colleagues?)

    I’ll be on the road for much of the time between now and the 25th, so I’ll take this opportunity, Ross, to wish you a very merry yet peaceful Christmas, sprinkled with plenty of New Year blessings.

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Paula Satinoff Thank you, Paula! Have a wonderful and witty holiday. I don’t anticipate much downtime until after Christmas myself. Holding on for dear life until January 2nd. 🫩

Leave a Reply

Tag Cloud

Aaron Copland (92) Beethoven (94) Composer (114) Conductor (84) Film Music (107) Film Score (143) Film Scores (255) Halloween (94) John Williams (181) KWAX (227) Leonard Bernstein (98) Marlboro Music Festival (125) Movie Music (122) Mozart (84) Opera (195) Picture Perfect (174) Princeton Symphony Orchestra (102) Radio (86) Ross Amico (244) Roy's Tie-Dye Sci-Fi Corner (290) The Classical Network (101) The Lost Chord (268) Vaughan Williams (97) WPRB (396) WWFM (881)

DON’T MISS A BEAT

Receive a weekly digest every Sunday at noon by signing up here


RECENT POSTS