Give a Hand for Gary Graffman

Give a Hand for Gary Graffman

by 

in
15 responses

Piano legend Gary Graffman has died.

Graffman had a powerful start as part of Columbia Records’ stable of American pianists that also included Leon Fleisher and Eugene Istomin, and he made some fantastic recordings with George Szell and Leonard Bernstein, until, like Fleisher, a hand injury drove him into semi-retirement as a performer.

Graffman was instrumental in resurrecting works in the left-handed repertoire, a number of them commissioned by pianist Paul Wittgenstein, who lost his right arm during the First World War. In particular, Graffman was a champion of the works composed for Wittgenstein by Erich Wolfgang Korngold, and I was fortunate (and thrilled) to be able to hear him play these pieces in Philadelphia at a time when they were not widely available on recordings. It’s so easy now to take for granted how spoiled for choice we are in this day of exhaustive recordings and internet access to them. In particular, I got to know Korngold’s Suite for Two Violins, Cello and Piano Left-Hand from Graffman’s concert performances (although it was Fleisher who made the definitive recording of the piece).

I also attended the world premiere of Ned Rorem’s Piano Concerto for the Left Hand (his fourth piano concerto) at Philadelphia’s Academy of Music, which was recorded live and released on New World Records. Rorem always was a miniaturist at heart, or that is my impression, so even when working in larger forms, as here, it was not unusual for him to construct them out of smaller individual components. The concerto consists of eight brief movements, as opposed to three epic statements in the grand German tradition. The outer movements employ kind of a twelve-tone “scat” – the way it’s handled, it’s not going to leap out and clap you on the ears as “twelve tone music” – but at its core, the concerto shares a French sensibility that might appeal to anyone who enjoys the music of Francis Poulenc. It’s an attractive piece, and I’ve played it on the radio many times.

It’s one of several works for left hand composed specifically for Graffman. In 1996, William Bolcom wrote a concerto, “Gaea,” for Graffman and Fleisher to perform together. In 2001, Graffman gave the premiere of “Seven Last Words,” by Curtis alum Daron Hagen.

Graffman’s recording of “Rhapsody in Blue” has enjoyed an especially lucrative existence, thanks to its use in Woody Allen’s “Manhattan.” It’s turned up in numerous film and television productions ever since.

Graffman found a second career as an influential teacher and administrator at the Curtis Institute of Music, where he joined the faculty in 1980 and became its director in 1986. In 1995, he also became Curtis’ president. He served in all three capacities – teacher, director, and president – for the next 21 years. I never lived more than a few blocks from Curtis, and I was a frequent concertgoer (also, my girlfriend at the time worked there), so of course I saw him all the time. What I didn’t see was his behind-the-scenes instruction of super-pianists like Lang Lang and Yuja Wang, who went on to stunning careers. Graffman’s own teachers included Isabelle Vengerova, Rudolf Serkin, and, informally, Valdimir Horowitz.

Graffman’s wife, Naomi, predeceased him in 2019. Their marriage spanned some 67 years. Although I did not know them personally, beyond the exchange of a sentence or two at a reception, they seemed like a lovely couple.

Graffman’s death unexpectedly conjures another era for me. Suddenly, I feel very far away from my 20s.

Gary Graffman died yesterday at the age of 97. R.I.P.

———

Graffman performing the rarely-heard Prokofiev Piano Concerto No. 4 – another Wittgenstein commission, but never played by him.

———

PHOTO: André Previn, Ned Rorem, and Gary Graffman rehearse Rorem’s Piano Concerto for Left Hand and Orchestra


Comments

15 responses to “Give a Hand for Gary Graffman”

  1. Anonymous

    A giant. His legacy continues through his students and recordings. For some reason I never heard him perform live but I did see him often when I lived in Philly.

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Sharon Falkowski There are so many musicians I could have seen and didn’t. But I am thankful for those that I did! Money was sometimes a consideration, but there were so many free concerts and student discounts. I wonder if I also didn’t take some of our good fortune for granted, assuming that there would be other opportunities. Of course, we were spoiled for choice back then. You couldn’t be everywhere at once, and it’s easy some nights to convince yourself that you’d rather stay in and give your ears a rest. There aren’t very many giants from that era left, alas. Plenty of fine musicians, but few with the history and experience these guys had.

  2. Anonymous

    I remember this photo shoot!

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Daron Hagen Wow! As I’ve mentioned, for three decades I never lived more than a few minutes’ walk from Curtis, and I attended concerts all the time, so I encountered all three of these musicians, and even chatted with them briefly. I probably talked with Rorem the longest. (I know from your memoir that you knew him very well.) I saw him and Graffman fairly regularly.

      One day, when I was in mid-20s, I walked out of my building on the 300 block of South 18th St., and whom should I encounter but André Previn! It was one thing to see these guys on Locust Street on their way to or from Curtis, but there was nothing down that way but residential neighborhoods. I was so startled, I blurted out something completely ridiculous. “Maestro!” I exclaimed. “Nice to see you!” To which Previn, with a wry smile on his face, responded, “Nice to see you too.”

      A few years later, around the time Deutsche Grammophon was releasing Previn’s Korngold recordings, I asked him if there was any possibility he’d ever tackle “Die tote Stadt.” He told me that he would love to, and that he and Renée Fleming had actually talked about it, but it would involve coordinating their busy schedules. Of course, it never came to pass. What a missed opportunity!

      As a composer and Curtis alum, you’ve had so many rich experiences with so many notable musicians. Thanks for sharing your memories, in your book and on your blog. A lot of what you’ve written really resonates with me. Good to know somebody else who remembers Little Pete’s!

      Happy New Year, and all the best for 2026.

      1. Anonymous

        Classic Ross Amico thank you so much for the affirmation and the reminiscence! It is a real shot in the arm! I’m terribly grateful to have been in the room because of the opportunity of studying at Curtis back in the day. I love your posts and never cease to get a frisson of pleasure and recognition when I read them. Onward, my friend: keep the flame burning! I will too.

      2. Anonymous

        Classic Ross Amico I ran into Jackie Mason outside Curtis, but I don’t know that he had been inside.

  3. Anonymous

    I had a chamber music class with him at Manhattan School of Music, and he was kind enough to remember that when he was at Curtis many years later. It’s my understanding that Naomi was a strong support for him, and contributed greatly to his very popular book, “I Really Should Be Practicing,” which pretty much sealed his fame. She may have written it.

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Zlat Zlat Interesting! I’m glad they left you with happy memories.

  4. Anonymous

    Wasn’t Claude Frank a part of that group of Schnabel’s last proteges.

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Andrew Petersen Frank was indeed a Schnabel pupil. While I don’t believe Graffman ever studied with Schnabel directly, he had a friend who did, so he was exposed to elements of the Schnabel philosophy. I used to see Frank and Lilian Kallir (his wife) at Curtis all the time too, as well, of course, as their daughter, Pamela Frank, who was only a student at the time!

      1. Anonymous

        Classic Ross Amico Claude and Lilian were among the most kind and brilliant performers I have known.

  5. Anonymous

    RIP Gary Graffman

  6. Anonymous

    I heard him in the 1960s in Columbia, South Carolina. He introduced me to Schubert’s Wanderer Fantasy. Even though the venue was used primarily for wrestling, his musicianship was so wonderful that the magic of the music has never left me. RIP sir

    1. Classic Ross Amico

      Kirk Heriot Isn’t it amazing? Musicians often wound up playing in venues such as gymnasiums. Perhaps they still do? I saw Vladimir Feltsman play in a gymn in Bethlehem, PA, back in the 1980s. It was the first time I heard the Liszt Sonata live. The music and performance transcended the prosaic surroundings. Afterward, people lined up for autographs, and I remember he politely declined to sign a book of Bach sheet music, explaining that to do so, he believed, would be disrespectful to the composer.

  7. Anonymous

    I performed with him when I was 19 years old. It changed my life, forever.

Leave a Reply

Tag Cloud

Aaron Copland (92) Beethoven (94) Composer (114) Conductor (84) Film Music (107) Film Score (143) Film Scores (255) Halloween (94) John Williams (181) KWAX (227) Leonard Bernstein (98) Marlboro Music Festival (125) Movie Music (122) Mozart (84) Opera (195) Picture Perfect (174) Princeton Symphony Orchestra (102) Radio (86) Ross Amico (244) Roy's Tie-Dye Sci-Fi Corner (290) The Classical Network (101) The Lost Chord (268) Vaughan Williams (97) WPRB (396) WWFM (881)

DON’T MISS A BEAT

Receive a weekly digest every Sunday at noon by signing up here


RECENT POSTS